In the Colts' preseason opener on Thursday against the Baltimore Ravens -- Warren's in-game NFL debut -- he caught all three of his targets, for 40 yards (13.3 avg.), including a 23-yarder in which he showed off his run-after-catch ability.

Penn State's Tyler Warren was one of the finest tight ends in college football last year. Now, he finds himself with the Indianapolis Colts after being drafted by the organization with their 14th overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft.

No surprise here, by first-round draft pick Tyler Warren is the Colts' top-rated rookie in Madden 26. He is also the highest-rated rookie tight end in the NFL after being the second tight end taken in this year's draft.